You are using an outdated browser. For a faster, safer browsing experience, upgrade for free today.


ISSN 2223-6775 Ukrainian journal of occupational health Vol.15, No 2, 2019

NazarenkoV. I., MartirosovaV.G., Cherednichenko I.M., Tikhonova N.S., Beseda O.Y.


State Institution "Kundiiev Institute of Occupational Health of the National Academy of Medical Sciences of Ukraine", Kiev

Full article (PDF), ENG

Introduction. Preventing adverse effects of industrial factors at workplaces of office workers, engaged in intensive mental work, is one of important problems of modern occupational health. One of the factors that can positively affect a human body and promote a high level of work efficiency is comfortable levels of lighting. However unfavorable microclimatic conditions can cause a negative impact. Therefore, studying peculiarities of the combined influence of factors of the work environment on humans is important for development of preventive measures, especially concerning active introduction of energy saving LED light sources.

The purpose of the research was to study peculiarities of the combined effect of lighting and high air temperature in a laboratory experiment and develop hygienic recommendations.

Materials and methods of the research. The combined effect of the air temperature of 21 ºС and 27 ºС and lighting of 200 lx and 600 lx were studied in the laboratory experiment. In general lighting systems, LED light sources with the color temperature of 4000 K were used. Four series of studies, involving healthy male volunteers (N = 8), aged 21 – 22, without any pathology in the organ of vision, were undertaken. The duration and frequency of experimental series were from 9-00 to 12-30 a.m., in a day. The integral parameters of the functional state of specific physiological body systems were evaluated: visual performance (according to the time of execution a complex visual task) and the average body temperature.

Results. The experimental studies of the combined effect of the air temperature in the range of 21oC - 27 ºС and lighting of 200 - 600 lx indicate that these factors actively influence the functional state of the visual analyzer and the thermal state of volunteers. On the basis of the results of the studies, the regression equations were calculated on the dependence of the visual performance and the human thermal state on lighting and the high air temperature. It has been established that the optimal air temperature (21 °C) and lighting (600 lx) within the exposure time of 3.5 hours contribute to 53% improvement of the visual performance as compared to its level at the beginning of the experiment, and the most unfavorable combination of factors (27 °C and 200 lx) results in its decline by 45%. The positive effect of lighting with the level of 600 lx on the thermal state of volunteers was noted only at the background of the air temperature of 21 °С; at the elevated air temperature of 27 °C the effect was not recorded (p <0,05).

Conclusion. Based on the analysis of the regression equations on the dependence of the visual performance and the human thermal state on the levels of factors used in the experiment, it can be concluded that the increase in the levels of lighting up to 600 lux cause a positive effect on the visual performance and the thermal state of volunteers, whereas the increase in the air temperature above the sanitary norms (25 ºС and higher) leads to signs of accumulation of heat in the body and decrease in the level of visual performance when conducting precise visual works.

The results of the research indicate the need of further scientific support in determining the effect of LED lighting on visual performance and the functional human state, taking into account the influence of other factors of the work environment for development of hygienic recommendations.

Key words: combined effect, lighting, high air temperature, visual performance


  1. Smith A., McNamara R. and Wellens B. (2004),Combined effects of occupational health hazards, Research report № 287, HSE Books.
  2. Guidelines for using Computers. Preventing and managing discomfort, pain and injury (2013), ACC Publication: URL: PRD_EXT_CSMP/groups/external./wpc090196.pdf (Accessed 05.07.2017).
  3. Office ergonomics. (2013), The European Agency for Safety and Health at Work, URL: (Accessed 05.07.2017).
  4. VlasovaE.M., Zaitseva N.V. and Malyutina N.N. (2011), “Peculiarities of the vegetative statusof individuals working with computer technology”, Meditsina truda i prom. ekologia, 2, 38–42.
  5. Chernyuk V. I., Nazarenko V. I., Apykhtin K.O. Chui T.S., Kudievsky Ya.V. (2012). "Physiological and hygienic evaluation of physical factors and intensity at work places of flight operators and engineering staff in air traffic management in Ukraine", Ukrainian Journal of Occupational Health, 1 (29), 26-34.
  6. Martirosova V.G., Nazarenko V.I., Dobrovolsky A.N. and Tereshchenko P.S. (2013), “Ethical issues in the introduction of new LED light sources in the work environment”, Vth National Congress on Bioethics, Kiev, Ukraine, 23-25 September, 99.
  7. Gornicka G. (2007), “Effect of lighting level and colour temperature on perfomance and visual comforn during the day”, 18-th NSWO najaarssymposium: Proceedings of 18-th NSWO Symp., 2 Nov. 2007, Amsterdam, 53–57.
  8. Tint P., Traumann A., Tuulik-Leisi V.-R. and Tuulik V. (2012),“Computer users health risks caused by the simultaneous influence of inadequate indoor climate and monotonous work”, Agronomy Research biosystem engineering,1, 261–268.
  9. Aladov A.V. and Zakgeim A.L. (2012), “About a biological equivalent of radiation from LED and traditional light sources with the color temperature of 1800-10000 К”, Svetotekhnika, 3, 7–9.
  10. Lee J.L, Moon J.W. and Kim S. (2014), “Analysis of occupants visual perception to refine indoor lighting environment for office tasks”, Energies, 7, 4116 – 4139
  11. Kozhushko G.M. and Dugnist L.V. (2015), “Specific requirements to LED lights”, Naukovyi visnyk Poltavskogo universytetu ekonomiku i torgivli, 1 (73), 42-49.
  12. Teksheva L.M. (2011), “Experiment: influence on the psychophysical indicators of a person. Comparison of fluorescent and LED lamps”, CROM Electronics, URL: (Accessed 05.07.2017).
  13. Martirosova V.G., Nazarenko V.I. Sorokin V.M. and Galinsky A.D. (2011), “Investigation of the effect of radiation from LED light sources on some basic physiological systems of the human body”, Svitlo luks, 2, 42–47.
  14. Martirosova V.G., Nazarenko V.I., Sorokin V.M., Galinsky A.D. (2011), Physiological and hygienic evaluation of radiation of light emitted diode sources of light. Ukrainian Journal of Occupational Health, 2, 27-35.
  15. Assessment of the human thermal state for substantiation of the hygienic requirements to microclimate at workplaces and measures to prevent cooling and overheating (1990), Methodical recommendation No. 5168-90, approved by the Order of the Ministry of Health No. 5168-90 of 05.03.1990, Ministerstvo zdravookhranenia, Moscow, Russia.
  16. Mathematical planning and evaluation of the results of the study of the combined effects of noise, vibration and microclimate in the work environment. (1986), Methodical recommendations № 4223-86, approved by the Order of the Ministry of Health No. 4223-86 of 10.12.1986, Ministerstvo zdravookhranenia, Moscow, USSR.
  17. Methods for determining indicators of visual performance (1985), Methodical recommendations No. 4052-85, approved by the Order of the Ministry of Health № 4052-85 of 12.12.1985, Ministerstvo zdravookhranenia, Moscow, USSR.

ORCIDID of authors and their contribution to writing the paper:

Nazarenko V.I. (ORCIDID0000-0002-5238-4312) – a literature review, formulation of the purpose of the study, planning of experimental studies and analysis of the results, conclusions.

Martirosova V.G. – choice of relevant methods for the study, studying visual performance of volunteers, computer processing of the data, analysis of the results, conclusion.

Cherednichenko I.M. (ORCIDID0000-0001-6654-1334) – studies of the thermal state of volunteers, hygienic assessment of physical factors and strain in the experiment.

Tykhonova N.S .(ORCIDID0000-0001-5856-9919) – control of parameters of the lighting environment in the experiment.

Beseda O.Yu. – control of microclimatic parameters in the experiment.