You can download the review template by following this link.
To the Editorial Board of the «UKRAINIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH»
I, ________________________________________
(full name)
__________________________________________
(scientific degree and scientific title)
___________________________________________
(place of work – institution, organization)
___________________________________________
Contact information ___________________________
(Tel., address, e-mail)
I recommend / do not recommend (underline) to publish the article______
__________________________________________
authored by _______________________________
(list of authors)
REVIEW
|
N |
Questions to answer when reviewing an article |
Evaluation criterion for "yes" or "no" |
|
1 |
Does the design of the article meet the requirements of the journal? |
|
|
2 |
Is there any new scientific information, which is of interest for publication in the journal? |
|
|
3 |
Is the issue considered in the article sufficiently up-to-date and relevant? |
|
|
4 |
Do experimental and/or theoretical methods meet modern requirements and the purpose set in the article? |
|
|
5 |
The presence of an abstract and its compliance with the content of the article |
|
|
6 |
Is the content of the article sufficiently systematized, consistent and without unnecessary details? |
|
|
7 |
Are the conclusions consistent with the results? |
|
|
8 |
Are the references to scientific sources adequate? |
|
|
9 |
Does the article meet the current standards of the English language? |
|
Conclusion:______________________________________________
Are there necessary any corrections or revisions of the article - yes / no (underline)
Declaration of conflicts of interests with authors of the manuscript – yes / no (underline)
If there is conflict of interests – please specify: __________________
________________________________________________________
(use as much space as you need for an exhaustive explanation)
Personal signature of a reviewer_______________________ Date_______________